Speech on the consideration of recommendation for removal of Adv. B Mkhwebane from the Office of Public Protector in terms of section 194(1)(c) of the Constitution
Speech by ACDP MP, Marie Sukers

Issued by the ACDP Parliamentary Media Office

Enquiry’s escalation of costs and Public Protector’s behaviour an “insult”

Sep 11, 2023

“Honourable Speaker,

There has been a concerted effort to discredit this process; the evidence leaders and parliamentary staff – most of whom are women – became collateral damage in an attempt to paint Advocate Mkhwebane as a victim of an abusive process and targeted conspiracy. The ACDP strongly rejects this.

The ACDP entered the process with an open mind to establish the facts on the matters before the Committee. This process brought into sharp focus the role of parliament and its oversight function over Chapter 9 institutions.

Our responsibility as office bearers is to maintain and uphold the principles of our constitutional democracy. It is our duty of office, and our duty to the people of this nation that should be our primary concern.

The cost of this enquiry is carried by the taxpayer. We cannot separate cost from the overall aims of the enquiry or the constitutional obligation of the individual who occupies this office. For us to not to mention the flagrant disregard for constitutional duty and obligation, as it relates to accountability, displayed by Advocate Mkhwebane would be amiss.

Mr Hassan Ebrahim, in his address to the Committee, likened the office of the Public Protector to a super hero. He articulated the intention of the drafters of our Constitution in an idealism that is regrettably missing in the public service today. The high ideals that would place consideration of the poor and vulnerable above self.

There is no greater form of elitism but for the poor to beg on their knees for their schools to remain open, and for public servants to have an open cheque to defend poor decision making in long drawn-out battles in court on the public’s dime. Such court expenses rob the poor of justice! Justice which they cannot afford in a court of law!

In the end, the deliberate delays, the escalation in cost because of it, and the behaviour of the current Public Protector, Adv Mkhwebane, through her legal representatives of choice, was an insult to this parliament of the people to which she is accountable. The process demanded fairness and an open mind. The principles of fairness to the individual, who is the subject of the enquiry, cannot be at the expense of the people of South Africa.

It is our submission that the outcome of the enquiry speaks to these principles of fairness but with the people of South Africa in mind, and the constitutional obligations put upon the PP foremost. The political theatre that grabbed the attention of the nation showed a blatant disregard for the ideals that so-called liberation heroes profess.

People like Mr Van Loggerenberg and Mr Samuel were mistreated in this parliament of the people, their right to dignity and fairness flagrantly disregarded, as was the concerns and rights of the people of Vrede – by those implicated in wrongdoing in the matter.

To occupy this office, I learnt in this process, would require much from the individual, and this parliament must consider the lessons we have learnt and apply them wisely in any new appointment.

The ACDP supports the recommendation for the removal Adv Mkhwebane as the Public Protector.”

-ENDS-

ACDP supports recommendation to remove from office Judge NJ Motata

ACDP supports recommendation to remove from office Judge NJ Motata

House Chair Whilst the highest standards are expected of a Judge, failure to meet those standards will not of itself be enough to justify the removal of a Judge. So important is the judicial independence, that the removal of a Judge can only be justified when the...

Parliament has been subjected to disruptions by the EFF for almost 10 years

ACDP supports impeachment of Judge President MJ Hlophe

Chairperson The ACDP wishes to agree with the Chairperson of the Justice Portfolio Committee, the Hon Magwanishe, when he said, “to whom much is given, much is required,” and the SCA has already found that “a Judge is the pillar of our entire justice system and of the...