Speech on Budget Votes 23 and 26: Defence and Military Veterans
Speech by ACDP MP, Steve Swart

Issued by the ACDP Parliamentary Media Office

Our deployed soldiers deserve the highest levels of support

Jul 15, 2024

House Chair,

The ACDP would like to extend its deepest condolences to the families and friends of the brave SANDF soldiers who have died in action recently as part of the SADC peacekeeping mission to the DRC (SAMIDRC). They have paid the ultimate sacrifice.

The question that we need to ask ourselves is whether these deaths were avoidable. Our deployed soldiers deserve the highest levels of support to carry out their duties and return home safely. These recent attacks have highlighted the deadly consequences of inadequate resources and support. Losing lives due to preventable shortcomings is a travesty.  The South African National Defence Union and other military experts have made it abundantly clear that there is a dire need for improved air support, medical facilities, logistical capabilities, and combat support, including crucial radar defence systems. It is time for decisive action to ensure that our troops are equipped with the tools they need to succeed and survive in their mission in the DRC or bring them home.

The famous lines from Lord Alfred Tennyson’s poem on the suicidal Charge of the Light Brigade comes to mind:

“Forward, the Light Brigade!”
Was there a man dismayed?
Not though the soldier knew
Someone had blundered.
Theirs not to make reply,
Theirs not to reason why,
Theirs but to do and die.
Into the valley of Death
Rode the six hundred.”

Chairperson, we in the ACDP respectfully believe that indeed someone has indeed blundered. We have blundered in not appropriating a sufficient budget to the SANDF, and in ensuring that the budget as allocated is properly spent. The soldiers who are deployed may not question the decisions to deploy them – theirs is not to reason why, theirs is just to do or die.

It serves no purpose to wring our hands and say, as many today have said, that the SANDF needs more funds and do nothing. We as Parliament appropriate the funds and must accept responsibility. The ACDP appreciates the fiscally constrained environment facing the country. However we can and must exercise our powers in terms of the Monetary Bills and Related Matters Act to reassign funds within the existing fiscal framework to the SANDF. If the SANDF is expected to assist the SAPS domestically in maintaining law and order, then the funds should be re-assigned from the SAPS budget.

In this 7th administration, Hon Minister, and more particularly DM with your military background – we must ensure our troops have the necessary equipment or admit that we are not up to the task and bring them home now and rather focus on assisting the SAPS in combatting the many threats to our domestic security – including rampant crime.

Let us ensure that our soldiers are properly resourced or bring them home now!

I thank you.

Stats SA is underfunded but what is being done about it?

Stats SA is underfunded but what is being done about it?

House Chair, Making tough decisions in an uncertain and fast-changing world requires a steadfast commitment to statistics and evidence-based reasoning. By grounding decisions in empirical data and sound statistical analysis, leaders can navigate that ambiguity and...

Special Housing Needs Programme a critical area of concern

Special Housing Needs Programme a critical area of concern

Chairperson, The 2025/26 Human Settlements budget is tabled against the backdrop of persistent housing backlogs, deepening spatial inequality, and mounting pressure on urban infrastructure. While the Department has made some strides in delivery, particularly through...

Department of Transport’s R95.7 Billion Budget “hollow”

Department of Transport’s R95.7 Billion Budget “hollow”

House Chairperson, The Department of Transport’s 2025/26 budget of R95.7 billion appears ambitious on paper, but beneath the surface lies a troubling pattern: bloated transfers, sluggish implementation, and a widening gap between policy intent and lived reality. A...

“Remember those in prison as if you were there yourself.”

“Remember those in prison as if you were there yourself.”

House Chair, The ACDP is aware that this department is a receiver department and so, as crime increases and as the call from society increases for more people to be locked away, this department has to receive more prisoners, both awaiting-trial and convicted. This...